It’s Biodegradable, I Swear! Part I

by Gia on March 21, 2012

Eco Friendly Dog


So after years of making fun of dog owners in the city, I became one myself: a city dweller with a canine friend. Meet Pepper. Of course now I think having a dog in the city is the best thing since sliced bread, but I still feel somewhat ridiculous picking up after Pepper does her business on the sidewalk. Luckily we have those tidy little poop bags to help us out and keep the mess to a minimum. I realize that using an old newspaper is probably more eco friendly, and I may just switch to that, but as I was getting used to this dog walking concept, using the bags just seemed much less disgusting.

So I walked into the pet store and asked for biodegradable poop bags, and the clerk pointed me to some bags hanging in a display case. On the packaging, there was a picture of the earth with some recycling arrows around it and the words “earth friendly.” If I didn’t happen to be in the sustainability field, I might have taken this information at face value and bought the bags. But I didn’t recognize the symbol as representing a reputable eco-label and I looked further. Nowhere on the packaging did the product claim to be biodegradable, compostable, or made of renewable materials. In fact, the bags were, as far as I could tell, no different than any other plastic poop bag. But I’m sure the manufacturer fooled a few customers into believing their product was “greener” than the next. How is this possible?

It’s possible, because there is very little regulation around what companies can claim as “green,” “eco friendly,” or “earth friendly.” Not that there isn’t any regulation – in 1992 the Federal Trade Commission came out with the Guides for the Use of Environmental Marketing Claims also known as the “Green Guide“. This regulation has been updated several times, and in October 2010 the FTC proposed major updates to this section of the Federal Register (the proposed updates have yet to be finalized). So this is all good, and the FTC has started to enforce these rules, but the rules are new, and in some cases unclear, and the door is still open for all the “greenwashers” and their claims for now.

So, as a consumer, knowing that the door is still open for marketers to make all kinds of green claims, how do you know what’s green? Well the first thing to know is that nothing is truly “green.” Everything we buy has some kind of environmental footprint. A product’s footprint is calculated using many factors: the material used to make it, the energy used to manufacture it, the gasoline used to transport it, the electricity needed to operate it, and the waste created when ultimately disposing of it. But a product can be “greener” than another. (The most environmentally friendly option is not to buy anything new at all and reuse what’s already out there!) So how do we know what’s “greener?” Currently, we at EcoPlum believe the best option is to buy products that have are made of recycled materials, have been certified green by independent organizations or that have earned a reputable eco-label.

Now, how do you know which Eco-Label is reputable? That’s the topic of Part II of this post. But, for now, here is a list of eco-labels we have found be run by independent non-profit or government third parties that appear to have no vested interest in the products or companies they certify.

[Note: the EcoPlum Online Boutique carries only eco friendly products that have been certified green, have a third party eco-label, or are made of recycled/upcycled materials.]

{ 2 trackbacks }

It’s Biodegradable! Or is it? How to Distinguish the Green from the Greenwash: Part II
May 10, 2012 at 9:04 am
It’s Biodegradable, I Swear! | CSRHub
July 30, 2012 at 2:05 pm

{ 2 comments… read them below or add one }

Beatrice Johnston March 22, 2012 at 3:34 pm

Wow Gia, This now makes me wonder if the bags we use for our dog are biodegradable. My husband says they “decompose” but now I am wondering if he was just under the “labeling assumption” that they would be. I’ll try to find out what brand we use, and if they are, I’ll let you know (they’re blue… but I think most brands are).

Gia March 26, 2012 at 2:22 pm

I know, pretty upsetting. Another blatant example of greenwashing through packaging/labeling is Poland Spring’s “eco-shape” water bottle. It claims to be green because it uses 30% less plastic than other comparable bottles on the market. Are they kidding? The bottled water industry is one of the biggest environmental disasters of our time. They have some nerve claiming to be “green.” We really need to be very informed when making purchasing decisions and not be fooled by claims and labels. And if we do use labels, we need to know if they can be trusted. Thanks for your comments, Beatrice!

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: